Counteroffer. Get reviewed

Executive offer letter - what to negotiate

Counteroffer · Answers · offer Source: https://trycounteroffer.com/answers/executive-offer-letter-negotiate

Short answer: Executive offer negotiations cover 12-15 specific items: base, equity grant, equity refresh, severance (6-18 months), Cause and Good Reason definitions, double-trigger acceleration, IP scope, non-compete scope and duration, indemnification, D&O insurance tail, 280G best-of-both, reporting line, board observer or director rights (where applicable), executive perks, and equity exercise window. The total negotiable value typically exceeds $200K-$2M depending on company stage and role. Always engage employment counsel; the stakes justify the cost.

The full executive offer checklist

Executive offer negotiation covers more items than ordinary offers because the stakes are higher and the protection items matter more. The checklist:

Compensation structure

  1. Base salary at or above peer practice for the role and stage
  2. Annual bonus target with measurable criteria, not pure discretion
  3. Sign-on bonus with reasonable clawback (12-month max, pro-rated, without-Cause exemption)
  4. Equity grant sized appropriately for executive role and company stage
  5. Equity refresh committed annually with specified floor

Equity treatment

  1. Vesting schedule: 4 years with 1-year cliff is standard; monthly post-cliff
  2. Double-trigger acceleration: 100% on involuntary termination within 12 months of CoC
  3. Non-CoC acceleration: 6-12 months on termination without Cause outside CoC scenarios
  4. Extended option exercise window: 3-10 years for any vested options

Termination protection

  1. Severance benefit: 6-18 months of base salary plus target bonus, depending on role
  2. "Cause" definition narrowed to fraud, willful misconduct, conviction of crime
  3. "Good Reason" termination with reporting line, comp, and location triggers
  4. Notice and cure provisions for Good Reason: 30-60 day notice, 30 day cure

Restrictive covenants

  1. Non-compete duration and scope narrow as appropriate to role
  2. Customer non-solicit limited to customers you serviced
  3. Employee non-solicit narrow scope and duration
  4. Confidentiality with carve-outs for industry knowledge

IP and indemnification

  1. IP assignment with state-law carve-outs (California § 2870 and equivalents)
  2. Prior Inventions schedule with all existing work disclosed
  3. Indemnification to fullest extent permitted by state law
  4. Advancement of expenses during indemnification proceedings
  5. D&O insurance with explicit tail coverage commitment (6+ years post-departure)

Executive-specific

  1. 280G best-of-both clause to manage parachute tax cliff
  2. Reporting line to specific role (CEO, board) confirmed in writing
  3. Direct reports specified
  4. Title and responsibility scope documented
  5. Board observer or director rights if applicable
  6. Executive perks (car, club, financial planning allowance) listed
  7. Travel expectations clarified
  8. Outside boards and advisory roles specifically permitted

Items that often matter most

In practical impact ranking:

  1. Equity grant size: Often the largest dollar item; cite peer data
  2. Equity refresh commitment: Future-comp protection
  3. Severance benefit: 6-18 months can be 6-figures or 7-figures
  4. Double-trigger acceleration: Critical in M&A scenarios
  5. Good Reason clause: Protects against constructive termination
  6. Indemnification and D&O tail: Limits future litigation exposure
  7. 280G best-of-both: Manages tax cliff for high-comp executives
  8. Non-compete narrowing: Future career flexibility

The first four items typically dominate the dollar value. The last four protect against specific risks that may or may not materialize.

Pitfalls in executive offers

Common drafting traps:

Cause defined too broadly. "Cause shall include any breach of policy" gives the employer constructive termination discretion. Push for narrow Cause: fraud, willful misconduct, conviction.

Good Reason defined too narrowly. "Material reduction in base salary" without including title, reporting line, or relocation triggers leaves you exposed. Comprehensive Good Reason language is critical.

Discretionary bonus framing. "Annual bonus shall be at the sole discretion of the Board." Acceptable for the amount, not acceptable for the existence of the bonus. Push for measurable criteria.

Equity refresh without commitment. "Employee may be eligible for additional equity grants." This commits nothing. Push for "Employee shall receive annual refresh of at least X."

Severance without bonus inclusion. Severance based on base salary alone, excluding target bonus. For executives with significant variable comp, this is a major omission.

Indemnification without advancement. Indemnification commitment but no obligation to advance expenses. Forces executive to pay legal fees out of pocket during proceedings.

280G not addressed. For executives at corporations likely to face acquisition, missing 280G provisions can be very costly.

Choice of law unfavorable. Some agreements choose the employer's state law in ways that disadvantage the executive (especially for non-compete enforceability).

How to negotiate

Executive offer negotiation is typically multi-round and involves counsel on both sides:

Round 1: Identify your top 5-7 items. Submit a counter covering them.

Round 2: Receive employer response. Adjust priorities based on what moved.

Round 3: Resolve remaining items. Compromise where appropriate.

Round 4: Final terms with documentation.

Throughout, counsel review every revised draft. Small wording changes can have significant implications at the executive level.

What to do next

For executive offers, the stakes justify both a Counteroffer review and licensed employment counsel. We deliver an offer review in 24 hours for $199 that identifies negotiable items and recommended language. For executive packages over $500K total comp or involving complex structures (280G exposure, M&A-related offers, multi-jurisdiction issues), we refer to specialized counsel. See Offer Review.

Sources

Related answers

Get your contract reviewed

If you want a delivered review of your specific document with cited authority and counter language, see https://trycounteroffer.com/offer.

Last updated: Sun May 31 2026 00:00:00 GMT+0000 (Coordinated Universal Time)

Counteroffer is a contract analysis service, not a law firm. This page is informational, not legal advice.